20 comments

  • mft_ 0 minutes ago
    Big karaoke fan, so thanks for doing this. I'm processing a first test song as I write. The pitch scoring sounds really interesting as both a competitive and maybe also a training tool.

    A couple of immediate small pieces of feedback:

    * The colour scheme on the queue/nn% buttons is really low contrast - white on pale yellow is very hard to read

    * the 'models' button (bottom left) - I assumed this would give me details about which models are available, and the sizes, but instead deleted the downloaded models without warning. Maybe add a 'are you sure you want to...' check?

  • Gormo 6 minutes ago
    Just downloaded source and built this to play around with it. I was a bit surprised that the first thing it did when I ran it was to start downloading binaries from the internet. It went off to fetch FFMpeg from some remote server, but I already have FFMpeg installed. Then it tried and failed to install its own Python interpreter, which is another thing that's already present on the system.

    How come this is trying to install its own vendored dependencies, including executable binaries, instead of checking for what's already installed? That approach can lead to both security and performance issues.

  • rzzzzru 7 hours ago
    I've been working on a karaoke app called Nightingale. You point it at your music folder and it turns your songs into karaoke - separates vocals from instrumentals, generates word-level synced lyrics, and lets you sing with highlighted lyrics and pitch scoring. Works with video files too.

    Everything runs locally on your machine, nothing gets uploaded. No accounts, no subscriptions, no telemetry.

    It ships as a single binary for Linux, macOS, and Windows. On first launch it sets up its own isolated Python environment and downloads the ML models it needs - no manual installation of dependencies required.

    My two biggest drivers for the creation of this were:

        The lack of karaoke coverage for niche, avant-garde, and local tracks.
    
        Nostalgia for the good old cheesy karaoke backgrounds with flowing rivers, city panoramas, etc.
    
    Some highlights:

        Stem separation using the UVR Karaoke model (preserves backing vocals) or Demucs
    
        Automatic lyrics via WhisperX transcription, or fetched from LRCLIB when available
    
        Pitch scoring with player profiles and scoreboards
    
        Gamepad support and TV-friendly UI scaling for party setups
    
        GPU acceleration on NVIDIA (CUDA) and Apple Silicon (CoreML/MPS)
    
        Built with Rust and the Bevy engine
    
    The whole stack is open source. No premium tier, no "open core" - just the app.

    Feedback and contributions welcome.

    • whilenot-dev 3 hours ago
      Just tried it with B.E.D - Walk Away[0], unfortunately it lost track of the lyrics after 30 secs (Model is "large-v3"). Will play around a bit more, as it would be great to have a working karaoke generator.

      Some quick feedback:

        - Needs a way to skip for-/backwards during playback to validate the result
        - Sentences seem to be recognized (first letter has uppercasing), but periods aren't added
        - Needs an option to edit results from the track analysis
      
      Thanks for keeping it FOSS!

      [0]: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=_MFT4H3VoNE

      • djtango 3 hours ago
        Periods in song lyrics?
      • rzzzzru 2 hours ago
        hey mate! thanks for your feedback.

        indeed, I'm running to two problems on the analyzer side: 1. align model sliding off (especially w/ chorus/back vocals present) 2. transcript skipping parts of lyrics in lyrics-heavy tracks (I tried a lot of russian rap, lol)

        happy for contributions as I'm not that experienced w/ machine learning side of the project, mostly it was emperical "tweak the parameters and look what is changed"

        • rzzzzru 2 hours ago
          also model only affects the transcript job (I need to make it clearer in the UI). For the alignment, it's a single model provided by whisperx
    • evanjrowley 1 hour ago
      Amazing work! I am thrilled someone was motivated to approach this problem and develop a creative solution like this. There are very limited options for Karaoke, especially in the FOSS space. Most Karaoke apps are super limited and that's driven many Karaoke enjoyers I know to YouTube in search of the songs they want to sing. This solution would give them the power to do even more songs, even better than what's out there now!

      Questions for you:

      1. What CUDA capability level is necessary for Nvidia GPU accelleration to work?

      3. Are there any plans to support iGPU/NPU accelleration on AMD and Intel? Asking because those chips are most common in the mini computers sold at low cost these days.

      My family members who love Karaoke and will be happy to try this. Looking forward to it!

    • solstice 4 hours ago
      Excited to try this out. How well does WhisperX deal with lyrics in say Mandarin or Cantonese? Does it output Hanzi?
      • rzzzzru 2 hours ago
        I haven't tried Mandarin and Cantonese, but tried Japanese. back at that time, it performed poorly. however, I've tweaked a bunch of settings since then, so maybe it has changed. Hanzi is a supported font and can be output, but the transcript/alignment quality might not be the best
    • defrost 3 hours ago
      Struggled somewhat with Tjamuku Ngurra by the Tjintu Desert Band, absolutely nailed Mariah Carey's Ken Lee.
    • antihero 4 hours ago
      This looks like awesome awesome fun! Will let you know how it runs. What a wonderful idea <3
  • upsuper 1 hour ago
    Really nice project, I'm looking forward to trying it!

    Would it be possible to process songs on one device, and then use the result in another, or even multiple? Or would it be possible to run as separate server / client?

    I ask mainly because the device I connect to my TV is definitely not the most powerful one, so it would be nice if I can preprocess the songs elsewhere.

  • 10729287 4 hours ago
    Open source, local and passion driven. The kind of news that make me believes in humanity again. Thank you, can't wait to try it this week-end !
  • Eckter2 1 hour ago
    Very nice!

    I've worked on a small toy project with a similar purpose in the past [1], though it's not nearly as polished as yours, and I've made some questionable decisions here and there.

    I have questions about pitch tracking. It seems you do track the pitch for scoring, and there's a line at the top of the screen that seems related but that I can't figure out. For my use case, an important feature of karaoke apps is displaying how "high" the next note should be sung, or at least some hints. Is it something your app can do and I just haven't figured it out? Or would it be a feature request?

    [1] https://github.com/eckter/karaoke_helper

    • rzzzzru 45 minutes ago
      hi there! pitch scoring is now pretty simplistic and the feature you're describing is not implemented. it's a great feature request tho!
  • mynameajeff 2 hours ago
    My wife is a huge karaoke fan. I'm especially interested in the pitch scoring since we usually play the karaoke games on older consoles for that exact feature. Nobody really makes games like that anymore without a subscription (and most of these good modern karaoke platforms are exclusive to east asia anyways). If this works well this could make for some really fun social events, looking forward to trying this.
    • echoangle 1 hour ago
      I don’t want to take away from OPs project (which seems really nice) but have you tried Ultrastar Deluxe ( https://usdx.eu/ ) in combination with USDB ( https://usdb.animux.de/ )?

      There’s also a program for automatically downloading the songs: https://github.com/bohning/usdb_syncer

    • wossab 1 hour ago
      What would you consider the best "Singstar-like" alternative atm?
    • rzzzzru 2 hours ago
      please try it out and share your feedback afterwards!

      both transcript/alignment might not work perfectly, but it really depends on the song

  • dmd 2 hours ago
    This looks great, but I don't understand what it's supposed to do. I assumed the idea was "remove the lyrics" but of the 5 songs I tried (from Cry Cry Cry, Indigo Girls, and Suzanne Vega), none seemed to have any change from the original at all - it's showing the words on the screen (and the timing is perfect) but it's not removing the singing at all. How do you turn off the singing?
    • rzzzzru 2 hours ago
      hey!

      you can use + / - buttons on the keyboard to change the level of guidance according to your preference, generally there is a controls legend in the top right corner

      https://nightingale.cafe/docs/controls

      • dmd 2 hours ago
        Yeah, I did that. I think the problem is when there are multiple singers harmonizing it only removes one.
        • rzzzzru 1 hour ago
          indeed! the stem separation model is not ideal. you can try to change the stem separation model in the settings and reanalyze the song (make sure to click the trash button and then analyze, refresh button does not refresh the stems, only the transcript/alignment)
  • reddalo 1 hour ago
    Looks amazing. I've been using Karafun [1], a paid service, but this seems promising.

    [1] https://www.karafun.com/

    • mock-possum 38 minutes ago
      Unfortunately karafun, like so many other systems, has egregious holes in its catalog. I hate playing the “this song? No… this song? No… this song? No…” game.
    • kikokikokiko 56 minutes ago
      Karafun is a paid service? I've seen their karaoke songs on Youtube for over a decade, I thought that was their business model.
      • reddalo 45 minutes ago
        Yes, the free songs on YouTube aren't customizable: there's a low voice guide that you can't turn off (or turn up...), and you can't change tempo.

        You can do this from their huge catalog of songs, using their official app or their web client: https://www.karafun.com/web/

        Plus, they have music quizzes you can play with many people using smartphones as remote controls. It's super fun for parties where people don't want to sing all the time.

  • skatedbear 40 minutes ago
    So cool! I'll try it with the steam deck. Being able to go to a party with just the deck and a microphone and have a karaoke with any song people want sounds good.
  • arvinsim 1 hour ago
    I am getting a virus detected error when downloading from Chrome.
  • caipira 3 hours ago
    This looks amazing! looking forward to test it on the weekend. Does it work well on a raspberry pi with 4 gigs of ram?
    • rzzzzru 2 hours ago
      oof, since it uses quite heavy models locally I would expect it to struggle on such hardware. M1+ macs & nvidia gpus work the best and fastest.
  • integralid 4 hours ago
    >app that works with any song on your computer

    Impressive, very nice. Now let's see my death metal collection.

    Just joking! Very nice, thanks for open-sourcing it.

    • rzzzzru 2 hours ago
      No joke, feel free to try it! The beauty of the approach is that you don't have any limitations. Just be prepared to degraded experience, sometimes models struggle even with the simplest pop tracks :D
  • manbash 2 hours ago
    This is very cool. I couldn't find it it already supports duets. I assume it won't.
    • rzzzzru 2 hours ago
      stay tuned for more features!
  • hasbot 2 hours ago
    I hate to be that guy that points out other projects but YARG has vocals and there are a slew of songs that can be used.

    https://www.yarg.in

    https://www.enchor.us/?&hasVocals=true

  • ETlol 3 hours ago
    VirusTotal says the .EXE is flagged by 1 security vendor but threat is low
    • rzzzzru 2 hours ago
      hey, thanks! would be happy if you open it as issue on gh
  • rjh29 4 hours ago
    I think you nailed it. Does it support pitch/tempo controls?
    • rzzzzru 2 hours ago
      not yet, but it's a great feature request!
  • Iamkkdasari74 5 minutes ago
    [dead]
  • jamesvzb 2 hours ago
    [flagged]
    • rzzzzru 2 hours ago
      I've just made it public a few days back :)

      need more pioneers to try it out and spread the word!

  • spacesxbt27 2 hours ago
    this is more nuanced than the title suggests. worth reading the whole thing