10 comments

  • SecretDreams 22 minutes ago
    The tools are good, but the ideas are not. These tools basically see many people building the same things independently, rapidly, and over and over again.

    I'm not seeing a lot of unique applications. I am seeing some optimization, plenty of rehashing the same crap. Lots of thought outsourcing.

    Honestly, I'm mixed as someone who also uses these tools. Is it really efficient for 100s of people to be spending tokens and electricity to all make, effectively, the same bad app from their shower thought/idea? I love that we've democratized coding so that it's more accessible to laypeople - but it is mostly all slop and lack of creativity being produced. And, in the rare instances where someone genuinely makes something good, 100x people will then spin their own AI to rip off the same idea.

    Where does this all go at the end of the day for humanity when nothing is new or creative and we are going backwards in critical thinking along the journey? Especially since the journey IS the thing for humanity - not the end product of the journey.

    • uptrails 12 minutes ago
      This really isn't limited to software. A more egregious example is music: we already had every genre, every mood, at our fingerprints practically for free. And now, we're just giving a big middle finger to human artists for no benefit whatsoever. Well, except that Spotify might be able to pay $0.0000 per stream instead of $0.0001.

      On some level, I understand where the individual impulse is coming from - "I couldn't do this and now I can, it's amazing" - and I can understand why amoral VCs would throw money at these platforms. But I will never understand why so many intelligent, sensible people are cheering for this future.

      Look at all the new book releases on Amazon. They are 95%+ slop, and not good slop. They're made with zero effort. Some of them sell because people judge books by the title & cover. What does this achieve? Once you eliminate all revenue for real authors, what next?

      • smallmancontrov 3 minutes ago
        Everyone makes crayon scribbles as a child. What does this achieve?

        Everyone learns the same basic curriculum in school. What does this achieve?

        Everyone makes mediocre attempts to play instruments/sports as an adolescent. What does this achieve?

        Everyone treads the same highs and lows of friendship and romance that have been tread by billions of others. What does this achieve?

        It achieves the human experience. Not everything has to be best-in-class to be meaningful, and that's a dreadful expectation to heap upon anything that doesn't strictly demand it.

    • InsidiousWombat 19 minutes ago
      I'm honestly massively disappointed.

      I expected tools when animator can just put a bunch of keyframes, sketch the transitions and have AI fill it in, getting all of the artistic vision with massive work saved.

      Instead industry went full on dystopia "let's replace entire jobs" instead of settling on just massive efficiency improvements on top of keeping the quality and we got million slop generators and little of the actual good tooling that would change the industry, outside of coding tools.

      • cccbbbaaa 10 minutes ago
        Well, filling transitions between key frames is an entire job: inbetweener.
      • surgical_fire 15 minutes ago
        > Instead industry went full on dystopia "let's replace entire jobs"

        That's the only thing the elites care about. They dream of not needing pesky labor anymore.

        • FLeXMurphy 9 minutes ago
          No wonder Hitler had so much support. They even called him man of the year. Then he turned on them.
      • gilrain 11 minutes ago
        > Instead industry went full on dystopia "let's replace entire jobs" instead of settling on just massive efficiency improvements on top of keeping the quality and we got million slop generators and little of the actual good tooling that would change the industry, outside of coding tools.

        You could try, collectively, uplifting the voices who saw it coming and called it out clearly in advance. They're the ones generally derided and dismissed as impractical weirdos, though, so that might be hard.

        As long as we instead uplift the greedy and craven, we will see greedy and craven results from otherwise neutral technologies.

    • miltonlost 18 minutes ago
      Democratizing coding via LLMs is democratizing cooking via frozen foods. It's gonna be unhealthy to the end user despite the convenience. And the taste level will not be there. Sure, you "made" dinner just like you "made" an app.
      • 220hertz 4 minutes ago
        There are startling parallels today to how news and information was 'democratized' when social media emerged in the mid to late oughties. The issue is the same: once it's cheap and easy no one seems to care about how healthy it is.
  • slowin 43 minutes ago
    The problem isn’t AI, it’s capitalism. I use AI constantly and have built my own personal universe of software. Instead of buying a solution, I build it myself. Instead of using open source, I build exactly what I need and nothing else. Instead of using a library and introducing a dependency, I just use AI to build it in my own code base.

    This has been revolutionary and game changing for me, but what it’s not is profitable in any way. In fact, quite the opposite. I also don’t even bother open sourcing or distributing what I build. It’s my computing dream, but it is just for me. Capitalism nor our idea of open source fit this model.

    • mettamage 35 minutes ago
      Relatable, computers are clay now. It’s a revolution but from the ground up and a quiet one
    • dominotw 30 minutes ago
      > have built my own personal universe of software.

      what are these and why did you do this? I am the only one that doesnt need custom software in my life.

      • slowin 22 minutes ago
        Many things from command line tools, to web services, to full blown gui environments. I do it to explore ideas and/or solve problems. Once I started, I found it incredibly powerful to control my own release cycles and feature development. I also found I don’t actually need a good chunk of what most products do.

        It’s funny because they say the first 80% is easy, but the last 20% of polish to get a shippable product takes most of the time. Well, if you just build for yourself and never ship, you can just crank your own solutions out at hyper speed.

        • dominotw 2 minutes ago
          ok its more like a hobby like model trains. I've been building stuff like that too.
        • opt3635 10 minutes ago
          > I do it to explore ideas and/or solve problems

          that's awesome. I wonder if you can name, like, a single problem you solved this way?

          • f3408fh 2 minutes ago
            Why are you being sarcastic? He solves problems he encounters, for himself. Why do you care?
      • antiloper 16 minutes ago
        NTA but I had the clanker build this for me:

        - A sane image editor for Linux, targetting the parts of Paint.NET that I need and skipping the rest (not having this annoyed me for decades)

        - Closed caption overlay using a local nemotron-3.5-asr-streaming-0.6b

        The latter I could've easily hacked together on a weekend myself, but I never had the energy to do it. Now it's (basically) free.

      • exitb 18 minutes ago
        Wait, what? Is the anti-AI goal post moving, on Hacker News nonetheless, at a point where we claim that building software is a needless whim?
        • SpicyLemonZest 4 minutes ago
          I don't understand why you see this as an "anti-AI goal post". It's precisely because AI is powerful at building software that we can no longer assume software is motivated by something beyond a needless whim.
        • runarberg 4 minutes ago
          Capitalists are known for pushing their customers into unhealthy over consumption to maximize profits. I would argue that 99% of all vibe coded software is nothing but throwaway toys, that gets used a couple of times and thrown in a pile of other unused toys which is quickly starting to take up all the space from your room.
          • dominotw 1 minute ago
            Things thats can be built with no effort have no value by definition.
    • 12391827 10 minutes ago
      You don't build anything. You are plagiarizing by the press of a button and are delusional enough that you think you accomplished anything.
      • piva00 6 minutes ago
        In that sense, plagiarising was always part of programming, a smart programmer would be able to analyse and lift parts of code to be remixed and re-applied.

        This moral ship has sailed, as much as you and I would like for it to not be true, if this is the world we need to live in I will do as OP and use these tools to achieve stuff that wasn't possible with my free time before. In that sense I think it's an accomplishment to be able to generate code for ideas I had but didn't have the time to properly code them.

        • 12391827 1 minute ago
          "It has always been this way." Do these talking points have chapter and verse numbers, like: Book of Amodei, 3:16?
    • hvs 32 minutes ago
      You wouldn't have AI without capitalism.
      • runarberg 8 minutes ago
        AI is capitalism. It is build by stealing labor, the models (i.e. the means of production) are owned by owners of capital who hand it to us if we pay them, i.e. rent seeking. If I am wrong, then AI is feudalism, which is not any better.
      • meindnoch 31 minutes ago
        You wouldn't have AI without anti-capitalism (open source).
        • jedahan 23 minutes ago
          Maybe Free Software or copyleft software would be more accurate/poignant.
        • slopinthebag 30 minutes ago
          open source is not anti-capitalist and in fact has thrived in our current capitalistic environment
          • ahoka 21 minutes ago
            Everything needs to exists in the "capitalistic environment". People, organizations, healthcare, church, software, activism. It's the environment we have.
      • InsidiousWombat 19 minutes ago
        You wouldn't have indoor toilets for everyone either, what's your point ?
    • 233mhz 36 minutes ago
      So the future is everyone throwing $x00/months to megacorps to rebuild the wheel forever?
      • neogodless 2 minutes ago
        When you say "everyone", how much of the general population do you believe is currently using AI to write their own software for daily use?
      • slowin 34 minutes ago
        No, I think local models will be good enough for this as long as Anthropic doesn’t lobby to lock them down.

        I can’t foresee what happens to the economy, I just know that I’m far more empowered than I’ve ever been before, and I’m not going back.

        • throwaway7783 30 minutes ago
          Do you code for a living? I'm asking because I'm curious if this is trend in general or among programmers
          • slowin 28 minutes ago
            I do, and have for nearly 30 years.
        • 233mhz 24 minutes ago
          Have you seen the prices of gpu/memory lmao? Virtually no one can run anything remotely useful locally and won't be able for the foreseeable future.

          There are maybe 100m people worldwide ready to pay $20 a month for a top of the line llm, no one will drop $2k+ on a machine to do the same at home with a gimped local model which brings 1% of the value since it won't be tightly integrated with anything

          • slowin 20 minutes ago
            It depends on how you define foreseeable future, I think we’re in a temporary state.
    • lopsotronic 17 minutes ago
      I would put a finer point on that, and say the problem is specifically highly-tuned financialized capitalism. Where "highly tuned" means that a LOT of resources are cranked to N degrees of precision about making money from calculated risk, where the actual value of those risk calculations is largely bollocks.

      I'm not throwing shade on the entire risk field, but I AM throwing shade at betting trillions of dollars on what you think a tiny fraction of future costs might be going off into infinity. It's what made image sharing or bond insurance appear more profitable than asteroid mining or solar power, and it's the leprechaun promising the pot of gold under the AI rainbow[1] for financialists.

      This happens to be a puzzle piece that fits pretty well together with several well-smashed shards of the Old European Right, but that's another subject and much more dubious. The "financialist thesis" of Western Decline is on much more solid ground.

      [1] I.e., eliminating all future labor costs forever

    • kamranjon 32 minutes ago
      “Instead of using open source…” - you might be surprised to discover what your models were trained on.
    • jstummbillig 28 minutes ago
      I do the same for my company. Behold, it's profitable. That happens when you put those efforts in the middle of something that generates profits.
  • josefritzishere 57 minutes ago
    [dead]
  • rdevilla 55 minutes ago
    [dead]
  • origini 1 hour ago
    The industry is just busy overall with day to day work and it just takes ages to implement things.

    Which also means that it is slow in adoption not because the quality is not here but because you need to do things first.

    You need an env to run an agent, you need connectors, you need to get that stuff through security etc.

    The only question is timeline not investment or bubble because AI as is will not go away anymore.

    I asked before for headcounts or consultants and today I can just use AI for it. Its not the AI which is the problem, its the stuff i mentioned above. We will probably still need a few month in my team alone to close the loop.

    And whlie we close the loop, models are continesly getting better.

    • t-3 50 minutes ago
      I don't think anyone is suggesting that AI isn't useful - that's been proven. What is being questioned is the business model and whether it's worth the investment necessary to train huge frontier models. How does one get ROI when models are continuously improving and being surpassed and people can distill your weights with a fraction of the cost and resources? How to insulate against the threat of local open weight models as hardware improves?
      • lambdasquirrel 39 minutes ago
        This is why it didn’t made sense to make OpenAI go private, instead of leaving it as a non-profit. If there’s no moat around building a dense frontier model, and others (like Google) already have a way to monetize a LLM better than you do, and yet everyone benefits from it, then it’s best left as a shared good.
      • petra 38 minutes ago
        It's a matter of national security at this point. So they'll probably find money.
    • ratelimitsteve 37 minutes ago
      the idea that a bubble means that when it pops AI will go away entirely is silly. the web was a bubble. we still have a web, and it's still useful, but a lot of people badly overinvested or invested in capabilities that never manifested and when the market corrected the price of those investments the bubble burst. same with real estate in 08-ish. A profitable idea drew more investment than it can support, prices went artificially high, then they came back down and we still buy and sell land.
    • reactordev 39 minutes ago
      Gotta setup your agentic software factory to generate requirements to feed into your factory to build your software that then needs CI/CD pipelines to deploy to production which requires more requirements for the factory to produce a working IaC repo against your repo and…

      …deploy.

      (Sir, The airspace is shutting down)

      Crap.

    • ActionHank 58 minutes ago
      That's some big cope you've got there.

      This isn't "AI is useless" or "AI is dead". They are saying it's not worth the cost.

      Further, I would argue that coding is the only place it's made solid headway and even then it either scaffolds to less than perfect, or the code base grows to be unmaintainable. Not saying you can't ship a product with it, just saying that while you are moving fast and breaking stuff someone else is shipping a solid product marginally more slowly.

      Last point "continesly" is not a word. Continuously maybe?

      • WillAdams 51 minutes ago
        Recently, I tried to automate a tedious aspect of my day job (renaming scanned check/invoices using information from each) and after a while, Microsoft imposed upload limits which reduced the number which could be processed each day to 80--100.

        I've tried to ask how much it would be necessary to pay to remove that, but haven't found an answer with a solid price.

        I managed to get a local LLM running and processing such files --- it took 405 seconds to process two on my work-issued laptop (by hand, with the aid of a batch file cobbled together from a spreadsheet I can do ~200/hr.) --- I need to do almost 5,000 of these for Q4.....

        • freecodeio 40 minutes ago
          and do you consider yourself responsible or liable if something goes wrong with those signatures?
          • the_sleaze_ 29 minutes ago
            Of course, exactly as much responsibility as there was having Microsoft do it.

            Or did you think he could have told the customer that MSFT messed up so no harm no foul?

            • freecodeio 28 minutes ago
              you're not the one I asked
              • the_sleaze_ 27 minutes ago
                Would you be more pleased to hear "AI bad" ?
                • freecodeio 25 minutes ago
                  do you also sign 5000 documents per month with an LLM? if so then, I apologize
            • opt3635 7 minutes ago
              > Or did you think he could have told the customer that MSFT messed up so no harm no foul?

              that is exactly the value proposition of software as a service

      • ragequittah 37 minutes ago
        Everyone I know who isn't anywhere near code uses AI daily. Law, telecommunications, real estate,. Some more effectively than others, law seems to be getting huge bump specifically (GLM law, Astra for law). I'm of the opinion if you aren't reliant on it now you will be soon.

        Does it cause problems? No doubt. People get way in over their heads with AI when they don't know what they're doing. But when you know your field and it's simply a conversation about busywork that needs to be done it's better and much cheaper than most assistants you would hire (unfortunately). It can save 10s of hours a week easily.

      • goosejuice 40 minutes ago
        > marginally more slowly

        I find it fascinating that you could hold this position. Pick a single popular SaaS today and you can duplicate it in a week. Of course that's not the only hard part of running a business, you need to market it and sell it. But that's millions of dollars and months to years of work reduced to nothing.

        Even marginal labor replacement in knowledge work leads to pretty significant revenue (not profit) figures split between the labs. I do think diffusion is relevant. It takes awhile to find product market fit and for new ways to work to become common place. We've seen this with most revolutionary technology (usually on order of decade+) and it's only been a year or so that these things have been good enough to replace some labor. I think we'll see incumbents who are slow to move on this get replaced by new entrants with much better margins.

        Not to say the hype isn't fucking annoying and often bullshit.

        • freecodeio 26 minutes ago
          you can repaint the monalisa with some robots but to what end
          • StableAlkyne 13 minutes ago
            The difference is that the Mona Lisa is art, created by a human. People generally value art because of the human factor - the artist was trying to say something, there is something interesting about the piece, etc. This is part of why generated images get so much pushback.

            The same cannot be said for SaaS: your business needs certain productivity tools in order to operate, and the only options tend to be these hyper-expensive SaaS options whose UX has been clunky since 2005. Historically, you could not build these in-house because it's more expensive to hire a full engineering team. Today, the math being done is whether it is worth it to build something 90% as good for 1% the price of the SaaS.

            • freecodeio 9 minutes ago
              problems evolve, hence why a saas is a subscription and not a disc you can buy with a license code

              clones are frozen in time and tend to rust and a financial incentive emerges to just purchase something that doesn't rust

        • mjr00 12 minutes ago
          > Pick a single popular SaaS today and you can duplicate it in a week.

          This is a common claim but I have not seen it played out in practice.

          The most well-known example people cite for this is Photocraft[0] which went viral a month ago; the claim was, at the time, that it was 80% feature complete upon release, and people took this to mean that Adobe was dead. The creator claimed that within a month there would be feature parity with Photoshop.

          Currently, their feature parity tracker[1] has them at 43%; a whopping negative 37% improvement in compatibility. Yes, this was a change in measurement, but by their own admission:

          > the 2026-10-03 estimate (82% "of the way") [...] counted feature surface and was far too optimistic

          The impending "SaaSocalypse" was predicted earlier this year, but never materialized, and you can see it in the stocks of Atlassian, Salesforce and others. They're getting hammered in the past few weeks as with all other tech stocks, but if you put all your money into Atlassian in June you would still have tripled your money right now.

          [0] https://github.com/storytold/photocraft/

          [1] https://github.com/storytold/photocraft/blob/main/docs/targe...

          • goosejuice 9 minutes ago
            > I have not seen it played out in practice.

            Of course. As I said it takes time. Writing the software is different than replacing an encumbant. A new software company starting with AI simply has less labor costs than any time in history. Claiming a competitor starting from the same place without AI is marginally slower is ridiculous.

      • phoghed 24 minutes ago
        > Further, I would argue that coding is the only place it's made solid headway

        Why? The company you work for seriously doesn’t do anything productive with LLMs?

        How about search? Every big company I’ve worked for has some shitty enterprise search. LLMs have massively improved that situation.

        They’ve also almost completely replaced L1 support at my company, the numbers there are way down just from people being able to find information they need. I don’t have broad numbers higher level support, but for a couple niches that I know about they are down as well.

        For example, in a global company of 100k+ employees you’d be surprised how many support requests HR got just for PTO related queries, not even real problems. Now we have an agent that can fully manage your time off, has the policy documents for every country, pulls your data from the HR system, their number of support tickets are significantly down.

        Another project I worked on involved automating some risk analysis stuff as part of the IT process everyone has to do when they develop or procure anything. After developing it for a couple months, then a few months running human in the loop validating all of the assessments, we have analysts manually audit 5% of them now. All of this used to be a shitty excel process, now is a slop web app. Cycle time is down from weeks to minutes because nobody has to wait on reviewers and the app can prefill most of the data from your general system documentation. Overall everything is just as or more accurate,

        I know these aren’t very glamorous, barely considered real work by some, but in my feeble imagination there are many such processes being automated and improved everywhere.

        • miltonlost 14 minutes ago
          > How about search? Every big company I’ve worked for has some shitty enterprise search. LLMs have massively improved that situation.

          Using Glean at work and it's not much better than bad searches. It frequently gives me outdated information, or uses questions I asked in slack as answers to the same questions I asked in the LLM.

    • metalliqaz 51 minutes ago
      > The only question is timeline not investment [...]

      This is not the only question.

      As my own organization has rushed/struggled to implement AI workflows, I have seen this same sentiment in many places in slightly different forms. The inevitability of it. The obvious benefits. "The revolution is here." Ok. Except why is it always around the corner? Why does the investment keep growing but the returns keep pushing to the right? Why is the answer to all the problems just "more AI"? From what I can see, it is very much in question that these intelligence products can ever integrate (in their current form) into our organization in a way that pays dividends on the investment. I'm really not confident that the current products are going in a direction that will ultimately help us. Instead what I have seen is groups of users that believe they are much more productive, but their numbers don't actually reflect any improvement.

  • yipinwong 0 minutes ago
    It took them 2 years for their people to report the hype? Or did they never follow what's been going on last 2 years? Hype's been there for years!
  • 999900000999 49 minutes ago
    It really looks like we’re starting to see the first failures of vibecoding ( vibe dev ops too) in prod.

    Can’t send emails, fly or check your bank balance. Ohh well.

    I would love to see 2027 be the return of QA across tech.

    • freecodeio 42 minutes ago
      they're already doing damage control by saying "the code was written by a human" which to me sounds so damn funny, you can tell the ai boosters are scared of reality catching up
    • drstewart 42 minutes ago
      What do any of those issues have to do with AI other than they happened loosely in an environment that contains AI and a bunch of conspiracy theory "it's obvious bro" connections?
      • slopinthebag 32 minutes ago
        they’re happening in an environment where companies and employees are claiming that ai writes all the code and is often handling the entire process through so-called “software factories”.
      • duskdozer 9 minutes ago
        It seems pretty reasonable considering the constant refrain of "nobody is handwriting code anymore" and such things.
      • 999900000999 33 minutes ago
        Mass layoffs justified by AI “productivity gains “ and essential services falling shortly after.

        Seems connected.

  • jrflo 54 minutes ago
    China seems to always have viewed AI as "normal technology". Maybe they know that they're falling behind and won't hit RSI like Anthropic thinks they will, or don't think that it's possible at all. Also notable that Baidu/Xiaomi don't have any frontier models, so it's a bit like Samsung commenting on the AI race
    • prometheus1992 47 minutes ago
      It's not about frontier models at all. They're commenting on AI as end users. They are saying the returns from the use of AI do not match the hype that has been created by the frontier labs.
    • inknight 48 minutes ago
      Xiaomi has MiMo, which is not "frontier" but still a good model.
    • unglaublich 50 minutes ago
    • pr337h4m 49 minutes ago
      Xiaomi MiMo is quite good.
    • ironborn123 16 minutes ago
      So you are saying Chinese firms are now going through the sour grapes phase.

      I am thinking maybe your blunt take is right. It is true their primary objective with distilling western models and open sourcing stuff has seemed to be to undermine the US economy. Cold war tactics, instead of running a normal business.

      Otherwise per their own admission why would they invest huge amounts, that too on student models.

    • locknitpicker 33 minutes ago
      > China seems to always have viewed AI as "normal technology". Maybe they know that they're falling behind and won't hit RSI like Anthropic thinks they will, or don't think that it's possible at all.

      If a leading AI company warns that there is a bubble, perhaps people should listen?

      The likes of OpenAI and Anthropic have an interest in keeping the hype going, as losing the hype poses an existencial threat. They are highly unsustainable as-is, and losing momentum won't make that problem any better

      > Also notable that Baidu/Xiaomi don't have any frontier models, so it's a bit like Samsung commenting on the AI race

      Nonsense. The ugly truth is that nowadays the cutting edge frontier models might unblock niche applications, but the cheapest models in the Pareto front are already handling the bulk of the prompts/sessions.

      And nowadays the only reason why cheap models such as GPT6 Luna are on the Pareto front is due to the fact that OpenAI rushed to slash it's costs in half right after it's release, in a desperate attempt to be close to the Pareto front and remain competitive.

      I'm confident that once hardware costs return to normal, the bulk of heavy AI users will jump head first to local models and US companies will face an existencial crisis. There is a reason why US government officials accuse Chinese open weight models of being economic warfare.

    • bilbo0s 36 minutes ago
      This is a bad take. The China market is different.

      Baidu and Xiaomi don't create models. That's handled by other entities in the China market.

      Baidu and Xiaomi experiment with models. Test the efficacy of different models. Get an idea of the relative economics of different models. Maybe create a model of their own to see if they can improve the business case in one dimension or another.

      What they're saying is that, in their role as customers for these models, they're a bit confused about the business case. I think that's a fair statement. They've presumably put a lot into finding out how to make money out of these models, and presently, the returns are not there with respect to the bottom line. Additionally, their experiments have given them enough background to feel comfortable asking, openly, where exactly everyone else feels the returns will come from?

      For them, yeah, just keep the little experiments going and don't go all in until someone offers you a model that can answer questions for less in cost than the person positing the question is willing to pay you. Maybe stay in verticals where the questions are valuable enough to be worth the cost for right now. Medical, Finance. And limit exposure to the larger market of less valuable questions: "ChatGPT, where is the closest pizza by the slice?"

  • lenerdenator 52 minutes ago
    I mean, yeah. They're deeply connected to the Chinese state and the Chinese state is trying to undermine the American economy, which has stupidly put a lot of its eggs in the AI hyperscaler basket.

    It makes total sense that they'd warn of this. They're also somewhat right. Not for the right reasons, mind, but they're right.

    • unglaublich 48 minutes ago
      It doesn't seem China is very agressive towards the Western economy? I'd argue it's much clearer that America is acting agressively towards China's (and other's).
      • metalliqaz 43 minutes ago
        China just has much better leadership and is not being loud about it.
      • InsidiousWombat 18 minutes ago
        Seems mostly "hahaha, look at those fuckers undermine themselves and cripple their own economy just to give us money for some cheaper labor"